I don’t think there’s a line of thinking I hate more in music discourse than criticism revolving around past performance. I wish this artist made music like they used to. I’d like them more if they still sounded like they did on the first album.
No, you wouldn’t. You would not care nearly as much about this performer if they intentionally or otherwise stunted their own growth and kept their sound confined to those rigid expectations. Can you imagine a world where instead of releasing Revolver, Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, and Abbey Road, all we got from The Beatles were 10 Please Please Me’s? How boring.
People love to say this about Zach Bryan, too. It feels like each new effort is constantly put up against American Heartbreak or Sweet Deann, this longing for a time when Bryan was writing at a higher level than most of his peers with half the resources.
Part of me gets it. There’s a certain novelty to an artist that gets lost once they break through and start giving way to label notes, scheduled co-writes, and all the other formalities that come with being more brand than creator.
But Bryan doesn’t operate that way; in fact, he’s hell-bent on staving off the staleness that can accompany being at the top of the mountain.
You can see it in his production, which gets sleeker and more defined with every release, in the all-star cast of collaborators he employs on these projects, and even in some of the stylistic choices he peppers throughout them. Bryan loves to wear his wide-ranging influences on his sleeve.
He’ll mimic Springsteen on a song like “Fear and Fridays” and then go into a fully fledged late-stage Bon Iver intro on “Lodi When” a few years later. It’s hard not to appreciate the diversity for its own sake, even if he doesn’t always stick the landing.
Zach Bryan is a lot of things, but a squanderer of opportunity is not one of them. Going from an untrained, on-the-fly performer to one of the country’s premier headlining acts is impressive in its own right, but doing so while continuing to challenge yourself creatively is a whole new feat.
It’s especially appreciated when the dozens of similar acts he spawned in the wake of American Heartbreak just can’t quite define themselves as well as he can. There’s a lot of credit that should be given to Bryan as one of the genre’s keynote performers for his continued willingness to try new things. The big swings alone are a net positive for the rest of country music.



